The Ultimate Back-to-School Mixtape

"I hate to tell you, but it's time for school." -- Sally Brown, Peanuts


In honor of another year of pencils, books, and teachers’ dirty looks, Editor-in-Chief Michael Roffman revisits his ultimate back-to-school mixtape. So, dust off those Yikes pencils and grab an apple, because it’s time to hit the stacks, folks.

I was born in late August and attended schools in South Florida, which meant two things. One, I was doomed from the beginning, considering the public school systems there are garbage. And two, I was always going to celebrate my birthday on the first day of school, which kind of sucked because nobody ever remembered it, and everyone was too busy to even bring cupcakes to class. Now, I wouldn’t have cared so much if not for the fact that everyone else in the class — from kindergarten to third grade, really — had special afternoons dedicated to their entrance into this world.

So, I wasn’t always thrilled about school. In fact, whenever I turned the page on my annual Peanuts calendar to see August, I groaned and sunk my head like the comic strip’s cardinal character. To me, the idea of going “back to school” was always a mixed-emotional thing. I hated to see the youthful summer days end, but I also looked forward to the holidays, especially Halloween, which always conjured up some sort of school-related party, dance, or after-school parade. Whenever my mother would insist upon getting new school supplies, I tried to put it off, for fear that it really meant that I was back in the classroom, staring at the chalkboard, and waxing nostalgic about the “better” days at the beach, wheeling around the neighborhood, or eating pizza late at night while playing video games. I’m talking about my college days — clearly.


Anyway, all that is behind me now. I don’t even own a Peanuts calendar anymore. But a couple of days ago, as I was walking through Walgreens looking for sugary cereal (so much has changed, har har), I passed an advertisement for school supplies and felt that jolt again. It had me laughing — but also thinking. As I walked home, I went through my long, storied history with school and thought about the assortment of lessons and stories that have stuck with me. Then I started sympathizing with those who still have to go back to school. The end result of that sympathy is a 22-track mixtape that captures all the mixed emotions tied to the institution we slave through for an average of 22 years. These choices, however, didn’t come without reason. In other words, consider this your late summer reading.

–Michael Roffman


01. The Beach Boys – “Be True to Your School”

Memorable Lesson: “So be true to your school now/ Just like you would to your girl or guy”

Reading Comprehension: It’s a timeless idea, no? Look beyond the dickhead teachers in the past, and instead think back to the times where you scored through the atmosphere on something you slaved over for days and nights, or frame the fragile moments in between: The love-fueled paper planes to the head of your all-time crush, the downright rotten concoctions at the lunch table that your best friend was paid five quarters to eat, or the two or three minutes you spent talking to your teacher when everyone else already cleared out of the classroom. Okay, so school’s something worth championing.

Take Notes: The song’s rallying cheer is an ode to Hawthorne High School in California, where Al Jardine and the Wilson brothers attended.


02. Paul Simon – “Me and Julio Down by the Schoolyard”

Memorable Lesson: “I’m on my way, I’m taking my time/ But I don’t know where”

Reading Comprehension: It’s unreal how much we take advantage of time as a youngster. Yet, in hindsight, there’s something comforting and enviable about not knowing what’s going on and leaving that up to the elders — no matter how insane or chaotic or untrustworthy they may actually be.

Take Notes: Not even Simon knows what “Mama saw,” as he told Rolling Stone’s Jon Landau in 1972: “I have no idea what it is… Something sexual is what I imagine, but when I say ‘something,’ I never bothered to figure out what it was. Didn’t make any difference to me.”


03. Al Green – “School Days”

Memorable Lesson: “How I wish for school days/ How we used to run and play, oh baby”

Reading Comprehension: “You can’t truly appreciate something until it’s gone.” I think that goes for just about everything as a budding adolescent. Those slower, carefree days on the playground are probably one of the few times in life where you’re actually supposed to do nothing but have fun. Don’t even get me started on how some days included both P.E. and recess. Who’s feeling nostalgic now?

Take Notes: Originally on Green’s 1974 semi-flop, Al Green Explores Your Mind, this particular track found some life by sharing a 45″ with the album’s only hit: “Sha-La-La (Make Me Happy)”.


04. Kanye West – “School Spirit”

Memorable Lesson: “Back to school and I hate it there/ Everything I want I gotta wait a year”

Reading Comprehension: Summer used to hold so much weight in our lives. It still does, but it’s just not the same. Those three months used to mean one thing: freedom. Now, they’re just three months where we sweat in our business attire and occasionally take a “cabin trip with old college friends.” Try and think back to the slow burn of your first day of school, how you almost felt like welling up with tears once August died down. In hindsight, it’s quite possible our excitement for school waned following our first experience with summer. That’s a real bummer for first grade teachers everywhere.

Take Notes: Yeezy samples Aretha Franklin’s “Spirit in the Dark” here.


05. Nazareth – “Love Hurts”

Memorable Lesson: “Love is like a flame/ It burns you when it’s hot”

Reading Comprehension: Heartbreak starts young, and it’s that first crack that stings the most — even if it’s a “stupid crush” on a “stupid girl” or a “stupid boy.” Nothing mends the wounds, and it’s something that sticks with you forever. But it’s one of the more important lessons in life to experience, learn, and move on from.

Take Notes: Nazareth took this one to the top of the charts, but it was The Everly Brothers who first recorded it. Other artists who’ve made it their own: Roy Orbison, Emmylou Harris, and Jim Capaldi.


06. Belle and Sebastian – “We Rule the School”

Memorable Lesson: “Do something pretty while you can”

Reading Comprehension: One needs to have courage to be oneself. School isn’t the most ideal setting for this, but it’s the only one that really counts as a kid. There’s a window of opportunity for everyone that’s open early on, when put-downs or criticism are still alien. “Kids say the darndest things,” Cosby used to preach, but really, kids know no other way. But because they’re so new to everything, there’s an element of spiritual freedom that carves out each and every kid’s identity. That’s a valuable lesson appreciated far too late.

Take Notes: Songwriter Stuart Murdoch found public appreciation in music as a DJ at the University of Glasgow throughout the ’80s. He did rule the school.


07. Pixies – “Weird at My School”

Memorable Lesson: “I’m a son of a bitch at my school”

Reading Comprehension: Sometimes harnessing that spiritual identity brings out the worst in someone. There’s a reason every class has a bully or an outcast. Some kids find their calling in the worst places, but sometimes those places just aren’t appreciated by enough people. Truth: Just because someone preferred the back row of the classroom doesn’t mean they weren’t scoring A’s.

Take Notes: This ratty ode about having “sex with the nuns” or taking a “plane to Colombia” was weird enough to be excluded from any of the Pixies’ studio albums.


08. Pearl Jam – “Jeremy”

Memorable Lesson: “Clearly I remember/ Pickin’ on the boy/ Seemed a harmless little fuck”

Reading Comprehension: Unless you’re a patron saint or just really moral, you probably picked on someone during grade school, perhaps in passing or among friends at the library or the lunch table. Depending on how that went down, it’s likely haunted you from time to time. These attic thoughts climb down in the late hours of night, when the mind wanders and you start thinking, for no reason at all, “I wonder what ever happened to…”, and that’s when the guilt keeps you up even later.

Take Notes: The song’s an ode to 15-year-old Jeremy Wade Delle, who killed himself in front of his classmates on January 8, 1991, at Richardson High School in Richardson, TX. Frontman Eddie Vedder felt “the need to take that small article and make something of it — to give that action, to give it reaction, to give it more importance.”


09. Why? – “Afterschool America”

Memorable Lesson: “Bones are bones my friend/ And you won’t find flags/ In a million years/ In the fossil record”

Reading Comprehension: The illusion that school is this grand, ol’ place washes away over the years, especially as one races toward their 10th birthday. You’re not a teenager yet, but you’re aware enough to discern between what’s real and what isn’t. When the fabric of the institution starts to disintegrate, that’s when one learns to be cynical, or what we thought of as “keepin’ it real.”

Take Notes: The album cover for Why?’s 2003 LP, Oaklandazulasylum, features a boy floating face down in a shallow pool. Is that not a fitting image?


10. The Decemberists – “The Sporting Life”

Memorable Lesson: “So far I had known no humiliation/ In front of my friends and close relations”

Reading Comprehension: “First comes love, then comes utter humiliation” is how the limerick should really go. Save for the pain of one’s first heartbreak, there’s nothing more damning and painful than losing face in front of everyone, especially those closest to you. As one grows older, disappointment becomes commonplace, but that initial sting is so confounding. And really, while everyone’s quick to applaud success, everyone’s equally prone to stare, point, and laugh at failure.

Take Notes: Sporting Life was once a weekly American newspaper that highlighted sports like baseball or trap shooting. It ran from 1883 to 1917, with another short run from 1922 to 1924.


11. Nirvana – “School”

Memorable Lesson: “No recess!”

Reading Comprehension: The beginning of sixth grade is a short, aching stroll through bummerville for that very reason. This is when one starts getting nostalgic for “school days.” Even at the tender age of 11, one passes by the gates to the playground with a resonant feeling of loss.

Take Notes: Kurt Cobain actually wrote the song as a study of the Seattle music scene and the band’s then-label, Sub Pop.


12. Harvey Danger – “Flagpole Sitta”

Memorable Lesson: “Hear the voices in my head/ I swear to god it sounds like they’re snoring”

Reading Comprehension: Few among us would tolerate interactions with a paranoid, delusional citizen, but isn’t that the very essence of a budding teenager? As children become teens, youthful confidence is battered to hell by betrayals, scoldings, whispers in the halls, and more nightmarish situations. To survive, most start strengthening their shells by withdrawing trust and subscribing to the early tenets of paranoia. It’s a fun time becoming a teenager.

Take Notes: Pole-sitting was actually a fad in the early 20th century. It’s related to Stylitism, or more specifically St. Simeon Stylites the Elder, who sat on a column for 37 years. In recent times, some have used the practice as a form of protest; for example, Peter Spencer went on a hunger strike 15 meters above ground level for 52 days.


13. The Replacements – “Fuck School”

Memorable Lesson: “Fuck school, fuck school, fuck my school”

Reading Comprehension: What’d The Beach Boys say again?

Take Notes: Paul Westerberg, Bob Stinson, Tommy Stinson, and Chris Mars are all credited as writers on this track, which means they all probably felt the same way about chalkboards and erasers. Hell, Mars was a high school dropout.


14. The Ramones – “Rock ‘N’ Roll High School”

Memorable Lesson: “Well I don’t care about history/ ‘Cause that’s not where I wanna be”

Reading Comprehension: By the time the bell rings for eighth grade, the only thing anyone ever really thinks about is high school. It’s that big step, the next phase, and where all the shit goes down. However, most students forget that they’re also making the simultaneous transition from the top of the totem pole back to the bottom. It pretty much sucks being a freshman, and the only way out is tomorrow — or being blessed with a really, really cool older sibling.

Take Notes: Halloween star P.J. Soles played lead character Riff Randall in the hilariously stupid 1979 musical comedy of the same name, which also featured New York’s finest punk act starring as honorary students in the school.


15. The Runaways – “School Days”

Memorable Lesson: “It’s a dangerous scene when you’re eighteen”

Reading Comprehension: Danger is an apt description for high school. Emotions run wild, tensions flare up, and the consequences are far more severe. Nobody suspects a wild scene in elementary school, but with high school, it’s a facet of every teacher’s lesson plans. Humiliation, heartbreak, and defeat are commonplace, but now there’s a new activity to enjoy: self-deprecation. To be honest, it’s not too perverse of a metaphor to relate high school to prison — the comparisons are uncanny. But here’s the real kicker: For most of us, only one of them is mandatory.

Take Notes: Joan Jett was about 19 when she released this song. So, clearly she knew what was up.


16. Kiss – “Rock and Roll All Nite”

Memorable Lesson: “You keep on dancin’ and the room gets hot”

Reading Comprehension: Homework sucks, parents suck, teachers suck, and life sucks. It’s a daily shit show of cynical activities, but there’s always one thing everyone (mostly) agrees upon: the parties. Teenagers spend so much time idolizing the forbidden, whether it’s drugs, sex, or booze, and there’s something vaguely charming about it all being so new to someone. Hey, nothing changes from here on out. Right?

Take Notes: Paul Stanley offers this one to Detroit, but he actually wrote it alongside Gene Simmons while living in Los Angeles. At the 1996 MTV Video Music Awards, Stanley exclaimed that “there’s only one nation, that’s Kiss Nation, there’s only one Rock & Roll national anthem: Rock and Roll All Nite, party everyday!” Nuff said.


17. Broken Social Scene – “Anthems for a Seventeen-Year-Old Girl”

Memorable Lesson: “Park that car, drop that phone, sleep on the floor, dream about me”

Reading Comprehension: Did we already say it’s an emotional time in high school? Obsession is a dangerous beast, but one that’s unavoidable. As human beings, we’re carnivorous for others, hungry for attention, respect, and adoration. In our early years, we tend to equate this with a sense of identity and purpose, and if we’re starved for it, we lose our minds.

Take Notes: Those vocals belong to Emily Haines. Kevin Drew once dated Emily Haines. Who’s obsessed with who?


18. Alice Cooper – “School’s Out”

Memorable Lesson: “Out for summer/ Out till fall/ We might not go back at all”

Reading Comprehension: It’s all a party until the next thing starts knocking. The transition from high school to college is an intriguing one. You feel whole, complete, and uplifted — the summer prior to college is one of the best. It’s also one of the hardest, as everything — where you live, who you see, what you know, and what you do — is about to change, hopefully for the better. But that’s all still dizzying speculation at this point.

Take Notes: Richard Linklater nailed this one with Dazed and Confused. Who doesn’t think of an angry Ben Affleck when hearing this? No?


19. Hot Chip – “Boy From School”

Memorable Lesson: “And I was a boy from school/ Helplessly helping all the rules”

Reading Comprehension: There’s a wealth of naiveté in one’s first year at college. Things race by at complex speeds, information washes down the proverbial drain, and it’s difficult to find a clear focus. School isn’t a requirement anymore; it’s at one’s own discretion, and as a result, there’s a new problem in town: existential crises. That first year is a blast, sure, but deep within there’s a voice screaming, “Who am I?”, and it gets grating fast.

Take Notes: The song’s original title of “And I Was a Boy from School” was shortened at the request of EMI.


20. The Jam – “Art School”

Memorable Lesson: “Young words are mumbled, they don’t always last/ It’s up to us to be sure they understand”

Reading Comprehension: School is nothing more than an endless battle to fit in. College turns that into a war, while simultaneously gifting you with the knowledge that the enemy is your own mind.

Take Notes: How about that! Paul Weller, bassist Bruce Foxton, and drummer Rick Buckler all attended Sheerwater Secondary School together in Woking Surrey, UK.


21. Mogwai – “I Love You, I’m Going to Blow Up Your School”

Memorable Lesson: Yeah, Heathers is still such a great movie.

Reading Comprehension: Shit gets rough sometimes. Deadlines, bills, grades, and work pile up, and they all speak volumes about reality. Welcome to life. Try and survive. Don’t self-destruct.

Take Notes: 2008’s The Hawk Is Howling marked the first album from Mogwai that didn’t feature any vocals.


22. Mr. Bungle – “Everyone I Went to High School With Is Dead”

Memorable Lesson: “We’ve graduated and grown/ From a real world once our own/ Yet we have proven them wrong/ By dropping off all along”

Reading Comprehension: “The only thing constant in life is change.” Your former classmates, best friends, or teachers may not be dead, but it’ll feel that way. As the years inch forward, more and more familiar faces become dusty acquaintances and fall by the wayside. They’re not dead physically, but perhaps emotionally. You’ll pass by them, possibly stop for a drink or a chat, but more often than not, these friends will feel alien to you. Why? They’ve moved on, too. Who knows, maybe Facebook has changed all that — or just made it worse.

Take Notes: Mike Patton isn’t behind this one. Bassist Trevor Dunn provided both the words and the vocals.

Click ahead for the complete playlist via Spotify…